| |
|
|
 |
|
U.S.
Representative Gabrielle Giffords |
 |
|
Ms. Giffords was
carried out on a stretcher |
|
|
U.S. Cites
Evidence of
Assassination
Plot
TUCSON, AZ &
SANTA FE, NM
(By
Marc Lacy
and David M.
Herszenhorn,
NYT)
November 15,
2010
―
Prosecutors
accused
Jared Lee
Loughner, a
troubled
22-year-old
college
dropout, of
five serious
federal
charges on
Sunday,
including
the
attempted
assassination
of a member
of Congress,
for his role
in a
shootout
that left 20
people
wounded, six
of them
fatally, on
Saturday
morning.
Court
documents
filed in the
U.S.
District
Court in
Phoenix
indicated
that
evidence
seized from
Mr.
Loughner’s
home showed
he had
planned to
kill
Representative
Gabrielle
Giffords,
who was in
critical
condition
with a
gunshot
wound to the
head. Found
in Mr.
Loughner’s
home, F.B.I.
special
agent Tony
M. Tayler
Jr. said in
an affidavit
supporting
the charges,
was an
envelope
with the
handwritten
words, "I
planned
ahead," "My
assassination,"
and "Giffords."
The details
of the
envelope
were not
disclosed.
The court
documents
say that Mr.
Loughner
purchased
the
semiautomatic
Glock pistol
used at the
shooting at
Sportsman’s
Warehouse in
Tucson on
Nov. 30. The
documents
also
indicate
that the
suspect had
previous
contact with
the
congresswoman.
Found in the
same safe
was a letter
from Ms.
Giffords
thanking Mr.
Loughner for
attending a
2007
“Congress on
Your Corner”
event, like
the one she
was holding
on Saturday
morning when
she was
attacked.
Along with
being
accused of
deliberating
trying to
take Ms.
Giffords’
life, Mr.
Loughner was
charged with
the killing
and
attempted
killing of
four United
States
government
officials,
among them
U.S.
District
Judge John
M. Roll, who
was killed;
a
congressional
aide,
Gabriel
Zimmerman,
who was also
killed; and
two
congressional
aides,
Pamela Simon
and Ron
Barber, who
were
wounded.
The
authorities
released 911
tapes of the
minutes
after the
shooting in
which caller
after
caller, many
of them out
of breath,
dialed in to
report
multiple
shots being
fired, and
people
falling, too
many to
count.
The director
of the
Federal
Bureau of
Investigation,
Robert S.
Mueller III,
who traveled
to Tucson
from
Washington
to oversee
the shooting
investigation
at President
Obama’s
request,
said at a
news
conference
that an
intensive
investigation
was underway
to determine
``why
someone
would commit
such a
heinous act
and whether
anyone else
was
involved.”
Early
Sunday, the
authorities
released a
photograph
taken from
surveillance
video of a
possible
accomplice
in the
shooting.
But the man
later
contacted
sheriff’s
deputies,
who
determined
that he was
a taxi
driver who
dropped the
suspect at
the mall
where the
shooting
took place
and then
entered the
supermarket
with him
when he did
not have
sufficient
change.
Ms. Giffords,
an Arizona
Democrat,
remained in
critical
condition on
Sunday but
has been
able to
respond to
simple
commands,
and her
doctors
described
themselves
as
“cautiously
optimistic.”
At a news
conference
at
University
Medical
Center, the
congresswoman’s
doctors said
that she was
the only one
of the
victims of
Saturday’s
shooting to
remain in
critical
care at the
hospital.
They said
that she was
lucky to be
alive but
would not
speculate
about the
degree of
her
recovery,
which they
said could
take months
or longer.
“Overall
this is
about as
good as it’s
going to
get,” said
Dr. Peter
Rhee, the
chief of
trauma
surgery at
University
Medical
Center,
where Ms.
Giffords was
brought by
helicopter
from the
shooting
scene
outside a
supermarket
north of
Tucson.
“When you
get shot in
the head and
a bullet
goes through
your brain,
the chances
of you
living are
very small
and the
chances of
you waking
up and
actually
following
commands is
even much
smaller than
that.”
Dr. G.
Michael
Lemole Jr.,
the chief of
neurosurgery,
who operated
on Ms.
Giffords,
said that
the bullet
had traveled
through the
entire left
side of her
brain “from
back to
front” but
said that it
had not
crossed from
one side of
the brain to
the other,
nor did it
pass through
some
critical
areas that
would
further
diminish her
chances of
recovery.
The doctors
said Ms.
Giffords,
40, was in a
medically
induced coma
but that
they had
awoken her
several
times to
check her
responsiveness.
While the
doctors
described
themselves
as extremely
pleased with
the progress
of her
treatment,
they
cautioned
that it was
too soon to
make any
predictions.
“This is
very early
in our
course,” Dr.
Rhee said.
“We don’t
know what’s
going to
happen, what
her deficits
will be in
the future
or anything
like that.”
The doctors
said that
brain
swelling and
other
complications
still posed
large risks
in the days
ahead.
Darci Slaten,
a
spokeswoman
for the
medical
center, said
the
congresswoman’s
husband, the
astronaut
Mark E.
Kelly, was
with her, as
were her
parents and
two
stepchildren.
As the
doctors
provided the
update on
Sunday, law
enforcement
authorities
tried to
piece
together
what
prompted a
troubled
young man to
go on a
shooting
rampage here
that killed
six people,
including a
federal
judge, and
wounded Ms.
Giffords and
13 others.
At the news
conference,
Sheriff
Clarence W.
Dupnik of
Pima County
described a
chaotic
scene of
terror and
heroism as
the shots
rang out. He
said one
woman who
was injured
in the
shooting
fought to
wrestle a
magazine of
ammunition
away from
the
suspected
gunman as he
tried to
reload. He
succeeded in
reloading,
the sheriff
said, but
was then
tackled to
the ground.
Officials,
who did not
name her,
said the
attack could
have been
more
devastating
had she not
tried to
stop the
suspect
The suspect
in the
Arizona
shooting was
apparently
at a similar
meet-and-greet
event with
Ms. Giffords
in 2007, the
sheriff said
Sunday.
“There was
some
correspondence
between
Giffords’s
office and
him about a
similar
event and he
was invited
to attend,”
Sheriff
Dupnik said.
He said he
did not know
anything
more about
the 2007
event or why
Loughner
would have
been invited
to it.
The
sheriff’s
office said
on Sunday
that a
search for a
possible
second
suspect
person had
ended. A man
seen in a
security
video
shortly
before the
suspect
shooter went
on his spree
had been
found and
interviewed
and cleared
of any
involvement
in the
shootings.
Investigators
said that
the man was
a taxi
driver who
drove the
suspected
gunman to
the scene.
Upon
arriving
there, the
passenger
said he did
not have
change, and
he and the
taxi driver
went into
the
supermarket
for change
and the two
then walked
out together
and
separated.
While the
authorities
have not
asserted any
specific
political
motivation
to the
shootings
other than
to say that
Ms. Giffords
was clearly
the intended
target, the
political
reverberations
continued to
be felt
across the
nation and
in
Washington,
where flags
over the
Capitol were
flown at
half-staff
in memory of
Mr.
Zimmerman,
the slain
congressional
staff
member.
The new
House
speaker,
John A.
Boehner of
Ohio, who
ordered the
flags
lowered,
decried the
attack in an
early Sunday
appearance
in his
hometown of
West
Chester, and
said it was
a reminder
that public
service
“comes with
a risk.” Mr.
Boehner
urged
prayers for
Ms. Giffords
and the
other
victims and
also told
his House
colleagues
to persevere
in
fulfilling
their oath
of office.
“This
inhuman act
should not
and will not
deter us,”
he said. “No
act, no
matter how
heinous,
must be
allowed to
stop us.”
He also said
the normal
business of
the House
for the
coming week
had been
postponed
“so that we
can take
necessary
action
regarding
yesterday’s
events.”
That
business had
included a
vote to
repeal the
health care
overhaul.
And
lawmakers in
both parties
began a
difficult
process of
soul-searching
about the
tone of
political
discourse,
as they
wondered
aloud if a
lack of
civility
might
somehow have
contributed
to the
bloodshed in
Arizona.
In a
roundtable
discussion
with
colleagues
on NBC’s
“Meet the
Press,”
Representative
Debbie
Wasserman
Schultz, a
friend of
Ms. Giffords,
said that
Americans
both inside
and outside
of
government
had a
responsibility
to temper
the
political
discourse.
“It’s a
moment for
both parties
in Congress
together,”
Ms.
Wasserman
Schultz
said. “We
absolutely
have to
realize that
we’re all in
this for the
same reason,
to make
America a
better
place.” She
noted that
House
Democrats
and
Republicans
would soon
hold
separate
“retreats”
and urged
that the
parties also
meet
together.
“I hope that
the
Democratic
and
Republican
leadership
will make a
decision for
us to have
some kind of
not-just-token
unity
event,” she
said. “We
should have
an event
where we
spend some
time
together
talking
about how we
can work
better
together and
then we can
move forward
together and
try to avoid
tragedies
like this.”
Mr. Loughner,
who was in
custody of
the Federal
Bureau of
Investigation
on Saturday
night,
refused to
cooperate
with
investigators
and had
invoked his
Fifth
Amendment
rights, the
sheriff’s
office said.
Mr. Loughner
had
exhibited
increasingly
strange
behavior in
recent
months,
including
ominous
Internet
postings —
at least one
showing a
gun — and a
series of
videos in
which he
made
disjointed
statements
on topics
like the
gold
standard and
mind
control.
Pima
Community
College said
he had been
suspended
for conduct
violations
and withdrew
in October
after five
instances of
classroom or
library
disruptions
that
involved the
campus
police.
As the
investigation
intensified
on Sunday,
police were
still at the
scene of the
shooting, a
shopping
center known
at La
Toscana
Village.
Investigators
have
described
the evidence
collection
as a
painstaking
task given
the large
number of
bullets
fired and
victims hit.
Mark Kimble,
an aide to
Ms. Giffords,
said the
shooting
occurred
about 10
a.m. in a
small area
between an
American
flag and an
Arizona
flag. He
said that he
went into
the store
for coffee,
and that as
he came out
the gunman
started
firing.
Ms. Giffords
had been
talking to a
couple about
Medicare and
reimbursements,
and Judge
Roll had
just walked
up to her
and shouted
“Hi,” when
the gunman,
wearing
sunglasses
and perhaps
a hood of
some sort,
approached
and shot the
judge, Mr.
Kimble said.
“Everyone
hit the
ground,” he
said. “It
was so
shocking.”
Ms. Giffords,
who
represents
the Eighth
District, in
the
southeastern
corner of
Arizona, has
been an
outspoken
critic of
the state’s
tough
immigration
law, which
is focused
on
identifying,
prosecuting
and
deporting
illegal
immigrants,
and she had
come under
criticism
for her vote
in favor of
the health
care law.
Friends said
she had
received
threats over
the years.
Judge Roll
had been
involved in
immigration
cases and
had received
death
threats.
The police
said Ms.
Giffords’s
district
office was
evacuated
late
Saturday
after a
suspicious
package was
found.
Officers
later
cleared the
scene.
Ms. Giffords,
widely known
as Gabby,
had been
speaking to
constituents
in a store
alcove under
a large
white banner
bearing her
name when a
man surged
forward and
began
firing. He
tried to
escape but
was tackled
by a
bystander
and taken
into custody
by the
police. The
event,
called
“Congress on
Your
Corner,” was
outside a
Safeway
supermarket
northwest of
Tucson and
was the
first
opportunity
for
constituents
to meet with
Ms. Giffords
since she
was sworn in
for a third
term on
Wednesday.
As a
Democrat,
Ms. Giffords
is something
of anomaly
in Arizona
and in her
district,
which has
traditionally
tilted
Republican.
Last year,
she barely
squeaked to
victory over
a Republican
challenger,
Jesse Kelly.
But she had
clearly
heard the
message that
constituents
were
dissatisfied
with
Democratic
leaders in
Washington.
Rabbi
Stephanie
Aaron, who
in 2007
officiated
at the
wedding of
Ms. Giffords
and the
astronaut
Mr. Kelly,
and leads
Congregation
Chaverim in
Tucson, said
the
congresswoman
had never
expressed
any concern
about her
safety. “No
fear. I’ve
only seen
the bravest
possible,
most
intelligent
young
congresswoman,”
Rabbi Aaron
said. “I
feel like
this is
really one
of those
proverbial —
seemingly
something
coming out
of nowhere.”
|
|
. |
![]() |
|
|